Rocky and Carlos Macaroni and Cheese Recipe
Rocky & Carlo’s has been serving Chalmette, just outside New Orleans, since 1965. The restaurant was opened by a group of Sicilian men, including brothers and in-laws. Locals know it for its generous portions and, above all, its baked macaroni topped with red gravy.
Some readers may consider this a casserole rather than traditional macaroni and cheese. They expect a loose, creamy dish, but Rocky and Carlos Macaroni and Cheese Recipe produces a firm, sliceable square with beautifully browned corners.
That’s exactly the point. If you prefer a spoonable, saucy bowl of macaroni and cheese, a stovetop recipe may be a better choice. This baked version is for those who love crispy edges and a firm slice that holds its shape on a fork.

Why This Baked Macaroni Stays Moist Without a Roux
Dry pasta is one of the most common complaints about baked macaroni. The usual culprit is pasta that has been cooked until fully tender before going into the oven. It continues to absorb liquid as it bakes, leaving the dish dry and stiff.
Perciatelli helps solve this problem. This thick, hollow pasta resembles a long straw. When boiled for just 8 minutes, it retains a firm texture and creates small pockets that hold melted cheese and custard.
The secret to the creamy texture is an egg-and-milk binder rather than a roux. Three eggs whisked into 2 cups of milk form a soft custard around the cheese as the dish bakes. Without flour, there is no risk of a pasty layer forming at the bottom.
Ingredients for Rocky and Carlo’s Macaroni and Cheese
12 ounces perciatelli: The hollow tubes hold custard inside, so each bite carries more than a surface coating. De Cecco is the brand I look for in the Italian aisle. Boil it short, since the oven finishes the job.
Bucatini works well in its place and is far easier to find. Barilla’s bucatini takes the same 8 minutes.
12 ounces medium cheddar, shredded from a block: Cheddar carries the dish, melting into the custard and browning on top. Cabot is my pick for its steady melt. Shred it yourself, because bagged shreds carry anti-caking starch that leaves the pan grainy.
Medium beats extra sharp here, since long-aged cheddar sheds oil in a hot oven.
4 ounces provolone, shredded: Provolone adds stretch and a mild tang that cheddar lacks, and it browns in lacy spots on top. I ask for a chunk at the Kroger deli counter. Mozzarella works in place of it. The pull stays, but the tang drops away. Low-moisture mozzarella melts better here than the fresh balls packed in water.
3 large eggs: Eggs set the milk into a soft custard that glues cheese to pasta. I use Pete and Gerry’s, since the yolks stay a deep orange. Crack them into a bowl first to catch shell bits.
Room-temperature eggs blend into the milk faster. I set them out while the pasta water heats. The target is about 150 grams of beaten egg.
2 cups whole milk: Milk loosens the eggs into a pourable custard and steams the pasta under the foil tent. Horizon whole milk is my usual. Cold milk straight from the fridge is fine.
Lactose-free whole milk drops in at the same amount, with a slightly sweeter custard. Skip skim milk, which leaves the custard thin and watery.
3 tablespoons unsalted butter: One tablespoon greases the dish so corner pieces release, and 2 tablespoons dot the top for browning. Land O’Lakes is what my freezer holds. Cold butter cuts cleanly into small cubes.
Salted butter works, though cut the custard salt to a scant ¼ teaspoon. Margarine tubs hold water and leave the corners soft, so I skip them.
1 tablespoon plus ½ teaspoon kosher salt: One tablespoon seasons the pasta water, and the half teaspoon seasons the custard. Diamond Crystal is lighter by volume than Morton, so use a scant 2 teaspoons of Morton for the water.
Table salt is denser still, so use about half the amount. Measure rather than eyeball, since the cheese brings its own salt.
¾ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper: Pepper is the only spice in the custard, and it keeps 16 ounces of cheese from tasting flat. I grind it from a worn Peugeot mill. Buy whole peppercorns, since ground pepper loses its bite within a few months.
1½ cups warm red gravy: Red gravy is the slow-cooked tomato sauce of south Louisiana, and it cuts through the rich pan. Rao’s marinara works when I do not have a pot of my own simmering. Warm it for 4 minutes first.
A plain jar of marinara also works. Spoon it on after cutting, never before baking, or the top steams soft.
Tools I Recommend for This Recipe
- Large stockpot: holds 6 quarts
- 9×13-inch glass dish: Pyrex works well
- Large mixing bowl: for the custard
- Whisk: blends eggs smoothly
- Box grater: shreds cheese blocks
- Tongs: settles pasta strands flat
- Aluminum foil: heavy-duty works best
- Instant-read thermometer: checks center temperature
- Colander: drains hollow strands
How to Make Rocky and Carlos Macaroni and Cheese
1. Heat the Oven and Prep the Dish: Set the oven to 350°F with the rack in the middle. Rub 1 tablespoon of butter over the bottom and sides of a 9×13-inch glass dish. Shred all the cheese now and toss the two kinds together.
My dish is a chipped Pyrex handed down from my aunt Rosalie. It heats evenly, which keeps the bottom from scorching.
2. Boil the Pasta Short: Bring 6 quarts of water to a rolling boil and stir in 1 tablespoon kosher salt. Add the perciatelli and boil for 8 minutes, stirring at the 2-minute mark so the strands part.
Bite one strand. It should bend without snapping and still feel firm at the center of the wall. Drain, then shake the colander for 20 seconds so water leaves the hollow tubes.

3. Layer Pasta and Cheese: Let the drained pasta rest for 5 minutes. Spread a third of it in the dish, then scatter a third of the cheese over it. Repeat twice, settling each layer flat with tongs. Cover the top fully. Bare strands turn hard and dark in the oven.

4. Whisk the Custard: Crack the eggs into a large bowl. Add the milk, ½ teaspoon kosher salt, and the pepper. Whisk for a full 30 seconds, until no white streaks remain.
5. Pour and Dot with Butter: Pour the custard slowly over the top so it seeps down between the strands. Cut the 2 remaining tablespoons of butter into small cubes and dot them over the surface. One mistake taught me to rest the pasta. I once poured custard over pasta straight from the pot, and it left cooked egg flecks. 5 minutes of rest prevents that.

6. Bake Uncovered: Slide the dish onto the middle rack and bake uncovered for 30 minutes. Turn the dish at the 15-minute mark. The top should turn golden, with dark brown edges where the strands rise. The edges should hiss softly. Early dark patches mean the oven runs hot, so cover the dish sooner.
7. Cover and Finish Baking: Spray the underside of the foil first so the cheese does not stick. Tent the dish tightly with foil and bake for 22 minutes more. The center should read 160°F on an instant-read thermometer. The custard should jiggle only slightly in the middle. Rim bubbles should be slow and thick.

8. Rest, Cut, and Sauce: Rest the dish for 12 minutes, uncovered. Cut it into 8 squares with a thin metal spatula. Spoon 3 tablespoons of warm red gravy over each square. Resting lets the custard finish setting. Cut too soon and the squares slump, with a thin pool of milk at the bottom.

Tips, Tricks, and Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Weeping Center: A puddle after cooling means the custard overshot 170°F. Check at 18 minutes under foil next time.
- Bland Middle: Dull flavor in the center means the pasta water was under-salted. Taste it before draining; it should taste lightly salty.
- Stuck Corners: Torn corners mean the butter missed the rim. Run a thin spatula around the edges before cutting.
- Papery Edges: Brittle rims mean the pasta cooked past 8 minutes. Pull it at 7 minutes next time.
- Loose Squares: Crumbling squares mean the custard did not reach the bottom layer. Tilt the dish and pour slowly into the corners.
How I Customize This Rocky and Carlo’s Macaroni and Cheese
1. Brown Gravy Version: Swap the red gravy for 1 cup of warm beef gravy, the choice of the brown-gravy crowd in Chalmette. The beef stock adds a darker, meatier edge. I serve it beside sliced roast beef.
2. Sausage Layer: Scatter 8 ounces of drained, browned Italian sausage between the pasta layers. The fennel seed in it cuts through the cheddar. This version carries a weeknight supper alone.
3. Ricotta Ribbons: Dollop 1 cup of whole-milk ricotta between the layers. It stays in soft, pale pockets, a nod to baked ziti. I bring this one to potlucks with garlic bread.
4. Creole Heat: Whisk 1 teaspoon of Tony Chachere’s into the custard and cut the custard salt in half. The cayenne and garlic in the blend add a warm back note. It pairs with fried shrimp on Friday nights.
5. Smoked Gouda: Trade the provolone for 4 ounces of smoked Gouda. The smoke carries a campfire note through the custard.
What to Serve with Rocky and Carlo’s Macaroni and Cheese
A rich pan wants something sharp and green beside it. I toss romaine with red wine vinegar, olive oil, and thin red onion. Dress it at the last minute, since cut romaine wilts fast.
Meatballs simmered in the same red gravy are the classic partner. Garlic bread works for dragging through leftover sauce. I buy frozen Texas toast when short on time. Green beans roasted at 425°F for 14 minutes add a crisp bite.
Fried chicken thighs share a plate well, since the crunch contrasts with the soft custard. Sweet tea or cold lemonade rounds out the table. Lemon sorbet closes a heavy meal.
Storage Tips
Let the pan cool at room temperature for no more than 2 hours. Cut the leftovers into squares and pack them into a shallow glass container with a tight lid. They keep for 4 days in the fridge.
Reheat squares in a 325°F oven, covered with foil, for 18 minutes. Add a teaspoon of milk to each square first. The milk steams back the softness that cold storage dries out. Let each square sit out 15 minutes first.
The microwave works for a single square. Use 70 percent power for 90 seconds and let the square sit for 1 minute. Full power turns the eggs rubbery.
Store gravy in its own jar. Sauce left on the pasta turns the top soggy by day two. For longer storage, wrap each cooled square in parchment and foil, then freeze for 2 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge.
Rocky and Carlo’s Macaroni and Cheese Recipe FAQs
1. Can I use elbow macaroni?
Yes. Pull elbows at 6 minutes, because short shapes pack tightly and keep cooking in the oven. Keep every other step and timing the same. Expect a denser pan, since elbows lack the hollow centers that hold custard.
2. Can I assemble it a day ahead?
Yes. Layer the pasta and cheese, then cover and chill the dish for up to 24 hours. Whisk and pour the custard just before baking. Add 8 minutes to the uncovered stage, since the dish starts cold.
3. How do I halve the recipe?
Use an 8-inch square dish and 6 ounces of pasta. Cut the cheese to 8 ounces and the milk
to 1 cup. Beat 3 eggs, then pour out half, roughly 75 grams. Check the center at 16 minutes under foil.
4. Can I use a metal pan?
Yes, though metal heats faster. Cover the pan at the 25-minute mark and check the center at 17 minutes under foil. Dark nonstick pans brown quickest, so lower the oven to 335°F for those.
5. Can I use evaporated milk instead of whole milk?
Yes. Use one 12-ounce can plus ½ cup water for the 2 cups. The custard sets a little firmer and takes on a mild cooked-milk flavor. Skip sweetened condensed milk, which would turn the pan sticky and sweet.
6. Is red gravy the same as marinara?
Close. Louisiana red gravy simmers for hours, often with meat. A jar of marinara simmered for 10 minutes with a smashed garlic clove gets near it. Add it warm, since cold gravy cools the top layer fast.
7. Where can I find perciatelli?
Italian markets and online grocers stock it. Look for perciatelli or bucatini on the label, since makers use both names for thick hollow strands. Buy a 16-ounce box and save the extra 4 ounces for another night.
8. Do I need a water bath?
No. The foil stage traps steam, and the custard is loaded with cheese, so it sets without a
bath. A water bath would also soften the browned edges, which are the best part.
9. Does the pasta need rinsing?
No. Rinsing strips the surface starch that helps the custard cling to each strand. Drain it well instead. Cold water would also chill the pasta and slow the first bake.
The corner square is the proof. Its edges turn deep brown after 30 minutes of bare heat. The center stays soft for 22 minutes under foil.
Rocky and Carlos Macaroni and Cheese Recipe
Rocky and Carlos macaroni and cheese recipe with a baked egg-and-milk custard and no roux. Ready in 1 hour 29 minutes.
Ingredients
- 12 ounces perciatelli
- 12 ounces medium cheddar, shredded
- 4 ounces provolone, shredded
- 3 large eggs
- 2 cups whole milk
- 3 tablespoons unsalted butter
- 1 tablespoon plus ½ teaspoon kosher salt
- ¾ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
- 1½ cups warm red gravy
Instructions
- Heat the Oven and Prep the Dish: Set the oven to 350°F with the rack in the middle. Rub 1 tablespoon of butter over the bottom and sides of a 9x13-inch glass dish. Shred all the cheese now and toss the two kinds together. My dish is a chipped Pyrex handed down from my aunt Rosalie. It heats evenly, which keeps the bottom from scorching.
- Boil the Pasta Short: Bring 6 quarts of water to a rolling boil and stir in 1 tablespoon kosher salt. Add the perciatelli and boil for 8 minutes, stirring at the 2-minute mark so the strands part. Bite one strand. It should bend without snapping and still feel firm at the center of the wall. Drain, then shake the colander for 20 seconds so water leaves the hollow tubes.
- Layer Pasta and Cheese: Let the drained pasta rest for 5 minutes. Spread a third of it in the dish, then scatter a third of the cheese over it. Repeat twice, settling each layer flat with tongs. Cover the top fully. Bare strands turn hard and dark in the oven.
- Whisk the Custard: Crack the eggs into a large bowl. Add the milk, ½ teaspoon kosher salt, and the pepper. Whisk for a full 30 seconds, until no white streaks remain.
- Pour and Dot with Butter: Pour the custard slowly over the top so it seeps down between the strands. Cut the 2 remaining tablespoons of butter into small cubes and dot them over the surface. One mistake taught me to rest the pasta. I once poured custard over pasta straight from the pot, and it left cooked egg flecks. 5 minutes of rest prevents that.
- Bake Uncovered: Slide the dish onto the middle rack and bake uncovered for 30 minutes. Turn the dish at the 15-minute mark. The top should turn golden, with dark brown edges where the strands rise. The edges should hiss softly. Early dark patches mean the oven runs hot, so cover the dish sooner.
- Cover and Finish Baking: Spray the underside of the foil first so the cheese does not stick. Tent the dish tightly with foil and bake for 22 minutes more. The center should read 160°F on an instant-read thermometer. The custard should jiggle only slightly in the middle. Rim bubbles should be slow and thick.
- Rest, Cut, and Sauce: Rest the dish for 12 minutes, uncovered. Cut it into 8 squares with a thin metal spatula. Spoon 3 tablespoons of warm red gravy over each square. Resting lets the custard finish setting. Cut too soon and the squares slump, with a thin pool of milk at the bottom.
Nutrition Information:
Serving Size: 1Amount Per Serving: Calories: 515
Keep the foil handy and let the pan rest for a full 12 minutes. Spoon warm gravy over each square, then hand the spatula to the nearest hungry person. A pan of perciatelli and custard needs nothing more than that wait.
